Skip to content
+
+
+
+

Comparison

Hotjar vs Microsoft Clarity: which heatmap tool should you use?

vs
Scroll

Short answer

For most small business websites, Microsoft Clarity is the better choice because it is free and still gives you session recordings, click and scroll heatmaps, and frustration signals like rage clicks and dead clicks. Hotjar wins when you also want to ask visitors questions directly, using on-site surveys and feedback widgets, or need more control over which sessions and pages are captured. Octopi Digital adds Clarity to most sites we build or audit and brings in Hotjar when the answer to why visitors leave can only come from asking them.

Who each one is best for

  • Hotjar

    Teams running conversion work who want heatmaps and recordings plus surveys and feedback from visitors.

    How we use Hotjar
  • Microsoft Clarity

    Any small business site that wants free recordings, heatmaps and frustration signals with little setup.

    How we use Microsoft Clarity

Want this working for your business?

Book a free strategy call and we'll show you where to start.

Hotjar vs Microsoft Clarity, side by side

  • Cost

    Hotjar
    Free plan with limits; paid plans for more data and features
    Microsoft ClarityStronger
    Free to use
  • Session recordings

    Hotjar
    Recordings with filtering and highlights
    Microsoft Clarity
    Recordings with filters and frustration tags
  • Heatmaps

    Hotjar
    Click, move and scroll heatmaps
    Microsoft Clarity
    Click, scroll and area heatmaps
  • Surveys and feedback

    HotjarStronger
    On-site surveys and feedback widgets built in
    Microsoft Clarity
    No visitor surveys
  • Frustration signals

    Hotjar
    Rage clicks and u-turns can be filtered
    Microsoft ClarityStronger
    Rage clicks, dead clicks and quick backs flagged automatically
  • GA4 integration

    Hotjar
    Works alongside GA4 and other analytics
    Microsoft ClarityStronger
    Direct GA4 integration to match recordings with segments
  • Privacy controls

    Hotjar
    Masks input and personal data; settings adjustable
    Microsoft Clarity
    Masks sensitive content by default; settings adjustable
  • Integrations with work tools

    HotjarStronger
    Connects to tools such as Slack and product platforms
    Microsoft Clarity
    Fewer third-party integrations

Still weighing Hotjar vs Microsoft Clarity?

Tell us how your business runs. We'll recommend the one that fits, and set it up for you.

  • Free strategy call
  • No obligation
  • Straight answers

Which should you choose?

  • Choose Hotjar if…

    • You want to ask visitors why they didn't book or buy
    • You run regular conversion tests and need feedback alongside data
    • You want feedback widgets on key pages
    • Your team shares findings in Slack or product tools
    Get help with Hotjar
  • Choose Microsoft Clarity if…

    • You want behavior data without another monthly bill
    • You need quick evidence of broken buttons and confusing pages
    • You already use GA4 and want recordings tied to it
    • You are a small team that will check recordings occasionally
    Get help with Microsoft Clarity

Our take

What our team recommends

Because Clarity is free and lightweight, we add it to nearly every site we build or audit. We connect it to GA4, set masking so personal details never appear, and then filter for rage clicks, dead clicks and visitors who reached a form without submitting. Those recordings usually reveal the fixes worth making first. We bring in Hotjar when numbers and recordings aren't enough and the business needs to hear from visitors directly, such as a short survey on the pricing page or an exit question on a booking form. Neither tool helps if nobody watches the recordings, so we turn what we find into a short list of changes.

Thinking of switching?

Switching is simple because neither tool stores data you need to migrate. Add the new tracking script, set masking and filters, and remove the old script once you've exported any recordings or survey results you want to keep. Historical heatmaps and recordings don't transfer, so give the new tool a few weeks of traffic before comparing pages.

Talk to us about a migration

Get a recommendation for your business

A short call with our team is the quickest way to the right choice, and a plan to get it running.

  • Free strategy call
  • No obligation
  • Straight answers

FAQ

Hotjar vs Microsoft Clarity: questions

Straight answers to what people ask before they choose.

6 questions answered

Octopi Digital founder

Still have a question?

Talk it through with our team on a free strategy call.

Book a Free Call

For free recordings and heatmaps, Clarity is hard to beat. Hotjar is better if you also want surveys and feedback widgets, which Clarity doesn't offer.

Yes, Microsoft Clarity is free to use. Microsoft offers it without paid plans for its core recordings and heatmaps.

Yes, but two recording scripts add weight to every page. A common approach is Clarity for recordings and heatmaps, and Hotjar only for surveys or for a limited test.

Clarity's script loads asynchronously and has a small effect on most sites. As with any tracking script, test page speed after adding it.

It can be, when personal data is masked and your privacy policy and consent banner cover it. Both tools mask form inputs by default, but check settings and local privacy rules for your audience.

Rage clicks are rapid repeated clicks on one spot, usually from frustration. Dead clicks are clicks on something that doesn't respond. Both point to elements visitors expect to work.

Still not sure which fits?

Tell us how your business runs. We'll recommend the simplest option that does the job, and set it up for you.